CO-167 Denial Code: Meaning, Causes & How to Fix It
CO-167 means a payer has determined that the diagnosis or diagnoses reported on a claim are not covered under the applicable coverage rules. Before changing a diagnosis or appealing, confirm the actual ICD-10-CM codes and service-line pointers, the policy used by the payer, and the coverage rules in effect on the date of service.
Key Takeaways
- CARC 167 means the reported diagnosis is not covered; it is not the same as an invalid diagnosis code, missing authorization, or a general medical-necessity denial.
- Check the X12-referenced 835 policy identification information (loop 2110 REF), when supplied, plus associated remark codes and the payer policy.
- Correct the claim only when the medical record supports a coding, sequencing, or diagnosis-pointer change; never substitute a diagnosis merely to obtain payment.
- Appeal when the documented diagnosis and service meet the applicable coverage policy but the payer denied them incorrectly.
- A CO adjustment usually represents provider financial responsibility. Verify the actual group code, contract, law, and notice requirements before any balance transfer.
What Does CO-167 Mean in Medical Billing?
X12 describes Claim Adjustment Reason Code (CARC) 167 as: “This (these) diagnosis(es) is (are) not covered.” Its usage note directs readers to the 835 Healthcare Policy Identification Segment (loop 2110, Service Payment Information REF), if present. Official CARC list.
On an ERA or EOB, CO-167 indicates that the payer applied a diagnosis-related coverage adjustment and reported it under the contractual-obligation (CO) group. This may reflect a diagnosis excluded by a plan, a service that requires a particular covered indication, an inaccurate diagnosis-pointer link, or a payer processing mistake. The code alone does not show which explanation is correct.
CO-167 Versus PR-167: Liability Matters
| Remittance | Meaning | What to Do |
|---|---|---|
| CO-167 | Contractual obligation reported with CARC 167. | Treat the amount as provider-side unless a valid payer correction or other lawful basis changes responsibility. |
| PR-167 | Patient responsibility reported with the same reason code. | Confirm benefit terms, notice requirements, and legal/contractual rules before billing; the PR prefix alone is not the entire legal analysis. |
| CARC 167 Only | Reason code shown without reliable group context. | Check the actual ERA/group code and supporting remarks before posting or transferring the balance. |
CMS explains adjustment-group liability in its CMS group codes reference. A CO amount must not automatically be moved to a patient statement.
Why Does a CO-167 Denial Happen?
1. The Reported Diagnosis Is Not a Covered Indication
A test, procedure, or treatment may be payable only for specified diagnoses under the member’s plan or an applicable Medicare coverage policy. When the documented condition is outside that rule, the payer can deny the service with CARC 167. The exact procedure, plan, service date, and coverage criteria matter.
2. A Valid Diagnosis Was Omitted or Linked to the Wrong Claim Line
The clinical record may support a diagnosis that was not transmitted, was linked to a different service line, or was sequenced incorrectly under the coding rules. Compare the EHR, billing workfile, clearinghouse version, and final 837 before changing anything. Not every payer edit is solved by simply changing the primary diagnosis.
3. Diagnosis Specificity or Coding Did Not Match the Record
An ICD-10-CM code may be less specific than the documented condition, reported incorrectly, or invalid for the service date. Code-set validity and coverage eligibility are separate questions: a valid diagnosis code can still fail a payer’s coverage requirements. Use the edition of ICD-10-CM that applies to the encounter date.
For encounters beginning October 1, 2026, consult the FY 2027 ICD-10-CM materials. CMS code files and effective dates and official coding guidelines provide the reference point.
4. A Medicare LCD, NCD, or Associated Billing Article Limits Coverage
Medicare coverage decisions may depend on an NCD, an LCD, and related Billing and Coding Articles. The diagnosis lists often appear in the associated coding article rather than the LCD itself. Confirm the Medicare contractor, geographic jurisdiction, and policy version effective on the date of service.
5. The Payer Applied a Policy or Claim Edit Incorrectly
A covered diagnosis may have been misread because of an outdated payer edit, incomplete transmission, incorrect plan mapping, or a claim-processing error. These cases call for evidence-backed reprocessing or appeal rather than an unsupported coding change.
How to Identify the Exact Reason for CO-167
Step 1: Read the Complete Remittance
Review the claim and service line, group code, CARC 167, any accompanying RARC, billed charge, allowed amount, and payer messages. Look for the 835 loop 2110 REF policy identification information, if available. Ask for the cited policy if the remit is vague.
Step 2: Reconstruct What Was Actually Submitted
Compare the final 837 and clearinghouse acceptance record with the EHR and practice-management claim. Verify ICD-10-CM codes, diagnosis order, service-line pointers, CPT/HCPCS, modifiers, payer/member identifiers, and date of service.
Step 3: Open the Exact Payer Policy
For Original Medicare, look up the NCD, LCD, and related Billing and Coding Article using the CMS Medicare Coverage Database. For commercial or Medicaid managed care, retrieve the member-specific benefit or medical policy effective on the date of service.
Step 4: Compare Policy and Documentation
Determine whether the documented diagnosis is covered for the billed service and whether claim data faithfully represents the record. If more detail is needed, request a coding query through the appropriate clinical documentation process; do not create a new diagnosis retroactively to secure payment.
Step 5: Choose a Defensible Route
A documented coding/pointer error generally calls for the payer’s corrected-claim process. A payer policy misapplication may justify reprocessing or appeal. A valid non-covered decision should move to contract and compliant liability review.
Medicare lookup resource: CMS Medicare Coverage Database. CMS explains that coverage diagnosis code lists frequently live in related Billing and Coding Articles.
CO-167 Resolution Matrix: What Should the Billing Team Do?
| Review Finding | Evidence to Verify | Recommended Action |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong Diagnosis or Pointer Submitted | Medical record, final 837, claim-line pointers, coding rules. | Correct and resubmit using the payer’s required claim-frequency/original-claim process. |
| Supported Diagnosis Absent From Claim | Signed provider record, coding review, diagnosis sequencing. | Add only the documented, correctly reportable diagnosis and submit a supported correction. |
| Diagnosis Accurately Coded; Payer Edit Seems Wrong | Policy effective on DOS, covered diagnosis list, remit and 837. | Request reprocessing or appeal with the exact policy passage and clinical support. |
| Plan Excludes Diagnosis/Service Indication | Plan document or LCD/NCD, member benefits, DOS. | Confirm valid noncoverage, contract obligations and lawful financial handling; do not rebill speculatively. |
| Wrong Policy Version Used | Policy effective/retired dates, payer correspondence. | Submit a targeted reconsideration or appeal citing the applicable version. |
| Different Claim Line or Service Was Denied | Line-level CARC/RARC, CPT/HCPCS, diagnosis linkage. | Resolve at affected line level; avoid changing unrelated claims or diagnoses. |
| No Policy Identified | 835 REF if present, payer portal, call reference. | Ask payer to identify policy/edit and applicable review route before changing or appealing. |
The decision matrix is a workflow, not a substitute for the payer’s claim correction, appeal, contract, and medical-record requirements.
Real-World CO-167 Examples
Example 1: Medicare Diagnosis-Coverage Edit
A Medicare claim for a covered-category procedure is denied with CO-167 and remark code N386, indicating the decision was based on a National Coverage Determination. The billing team identifies the NCD and relevant coding instructions, checks the date-of-service diagnosis against the applicable policy, and reviews the documentation.
If a covered diagnosis was correctly documented but omitted from the submitted claim, a supported claim correction may be appropriate. If coding was accurate and the decision conflicts with the NCD, the team can consider a Medicare redetermination.
This is based on the type of adjudication documented in CMS renal denervation claims guidance, which specifies CARC 167 and N386 for certain diagnosis-related coverage denials. It is a workflow example, not a promise that every CO-167 denial uses N386.
Example 2: The Documented Diagnosis Was Linked to the Wrong Service
A clinic bills two different services on one professional claim. The denied line points to a diagnosis that is unrelated to the medical policy for that service, even though another diagnosis documented for that visit may support the billed service.
After reviewing the signed note and final 837, the coder corrects the supported pointer and follows the payer’s corrected-claim instructions. The team retains the original and corrected claim versions for audit.
Example 3: The Diagnosis Is Not Covered Under the Actual Benefit
A provider confirms that the reported diagnosis and procedure are accurate but the member’s plan expressly excludes the indication. Filing repeated appeals without a policy basis is unlikely to fix the underlying issue.
The billing team documents the exclusion, confirms applicable contract and patient-notice rules, and improves its pre-service coverage review for future cases.
Can You Appeal a CO-167 Denial?
Yes, when the claim was correctly coded and the payer’s coverage decision appears inconsistent with the governing policy, a documented appeal may be appropriate. Begin with the payer’s stated denial reason, the policy in force on the service date, and the relevant clinical evidence. Do not substitute a diagnosis code simply because it appears on a covered list.
- Claim and service-line identifiers, payer reference number, remittance date, and complete CARC/RARC details.
- The exact covered-diagnosis or coverage-policy language, including effective dates and the policy identifier.
- Medical record entries that support the billed diagnosis and the service, with correct dates and signatures.
- The final submitted claim, diagnosis-pointer details, and any payer or clearinghouse correction history.
- A concise explanation of why the payer should reconsider the specific service line and requested outcome.
For Original Medicare, CMS says the first-level redetermination request is generally due within 120 days of receiving the initial determination. CMS first-level appeal guidance explains the rule. Commercial and Medicaid managed care deadlines vary: use the specific payer notice and contract.
CO-167 vs. CO-11, CO-50, CO-96, and CO-204
| Code | Core Issue | Why It Is Different |
|---|---|---|
| CO-167 | The reported diagnosis is not covered. | Investigate diagnosis coverage and the policy identification segment. |
| CO-11 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with the procedure. | Focus on diagnosis-to-procedure consistency, not necessarily a diagnosis exclusion. |
| CO-50 | The payer considers the service not medically necessary. | Focus on clinical necessity criteria and supporting documentation. |
| CO-96 | Non-covered charge(s). | A broad noncoverage adjustment that generally needs explanatory remark detail. |
| CO-204 | Service, equipment, or drug is not covered under current benefits. | Focus on benefit category or item/service exclusion, not only the diagnosis. |
Related Droidal reference pages: CO-11 | CO-50 | CO-96 | CO-204
How to Prevent Repeat CO-167 Denials
Use Policy-Informed Checks for High-Risk Services
Maintain date-sensitive CPT/HCPCS-to-diagnosis coverage rules where payer documentation supports them. Do not assume that a positive eligibility transaction verifies the medical policy for every service.
Protect Diagnosis Pointers Across Systems
Validate how the EHR, practice management system, clearinghouse, and final 837 preserve diagnosis codes, order, and line-level links.
Keep Coding and Policy Libraries Current
Review annual ICD-10-CM changes and payer policy updates. Archive effective-date versions so staff can validate historical denials without using today’s policy for an older service.
Build a Repeat-Denial Feedback Loop
Trend CO-167 by payer, procedure, diagnosis, referring provider when applicable, site, and denial outcome. Separate preventable submission errors from valid benefit exclusions and payer processing errors.
Route Exceptions to the Correct Specialist
Use coding review for diagnosis issues, coverage review for policy questions, and denial/AR teams for the appropriate correction or appeal path. Document decisions for repeatable follow-up.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Does Denial Code CO-167 Mean?
It means the payer reported that the diagnosis or diagnoses on a claim are not covered under the applicable policy or benefit. X12 defines reason code 167; the CO prefix identifies the reported adjustment group.
Is CO-167 the Same as CO-11?
No. CO-11 addresses a diagnosis that is inconsistent with the billed procedure. CO-167 addresses a diagnosis-coverage determination. The evidence and next action may differ.
Does CO-167 Mean the Diagnosis Code Is Invalid?
Not necessarily. An ICD-10-CM code can be valid for the service date but not meet a payer’s covered-diagnosis criteria for a particular service.
Should We Change the Diagnosis Code to Get the Claim Paid?
Only when clinical documentation and official coding rules support a change. Adding or substituting an unsupported diagnosis to meet a coverage edit is not appropriate.
Where Do I Find the Specific Policy Behind the Denial?
Review the remittance remarks and the 835 loop 2110 policy identification REF when present. For Original Medicare, check the applicable NCD, LCD, and related Billing and Coding Article; ask the payer for the policy identifier if it is missing.
Can a CO-167 Denial Be Appealed?
Yes when the correctly documented diagnosis and billed service meet coverage rules or the payer applied the wrong policy. Follow the actual payer’s appeal instructions and deadline.
Can the Practice Bill the Patient for CO-167?
Do not automatically transfer a CO adjustment to the patient. CO generally denotes provider responsibility; any patient charge requires separate confirmation of payer, contract, applicable law, and valid notice requirements.
How Do We Reduce CO-167 Denials Across Locations?
Track payer/procedure/diagnosis patterns, validate documented diagnosis pointers, maintain effective-date policy rules, and escalate repeat payer-specific edits to coding and revenue cycle leads.